JJ & A Axles

[ZillaFreak]

1 minute ago, trickedcarbine said:

You're adding variables to my question. I'm talking same size. 

I also understand the strength being stronger on a solid part, but sometimes a part that can handle some flex lives longer then a heavy solid part that would rather snap then twist. At least that's my minimal experience. 

 

I didn't add any variable. I said if you keep the OD the same on a shaft and only add a center hole, the solid will withstand more force before failure.

If you keep the cross-sectional area the same, then hollow would be stronger.

[trickedcarbine]

1 minute ago, ZillaFreak said:

I didn't add any variable. I said if you keep the OD the same on a shaft and only add a center hole, the solid will withstand more force before failure.

If you keep the cross-sectional area the same, then hollow would be stronger.

Deleted variable part as you posted. 

Makes sense though.

 

[locogato11283]

Hollow = stronger than solid

[ClaudeMachining]

16 minutes ago, locogato11283 said:

Hollow = stronger than solid

SMH...

[JUSTWANNARACE]

Apparently non of you guys watched MR. WIZARD growing up. 

[JUSTWANNARACE]

Can't belive I found this but watch the whole thing. I remember that shit from when I used to watch it as a kid..lol

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3Dl8umqZay434&ved=0ahUKEwi14anprZ7XAhVT2GMKHV0dDU0QwqsBCDEwBQ&usg=AOvVaw3nNtKso9Cads9A9nEoxiUM

[locogato11283]

1 hour ago, ClaudeMachining said:

SMH...

Only if you wash your hand first.

[JTmachining]

How did I know Zilla gona copy n paste. Multiple dimensions ads a dimension and can increase strength in certain designs/applications. Real world experience talk

[ZillaFreak]

1 hour ago, JUSTWANNARACE said:

Can't belive I found this but watch the whole thing. I remember that shit from when I used to watch it as a kid..lol

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://m.youtube.com/watch%3Fv%3Dl8umqZay434&ved=0ahUKEwi14anprZ7XAhVT2GMKHV0dDU0QwqsBCDEwBQ&usg=AOvVaw3nNtKso9Cads9A9nEoxiUM

Ya, the hollow bar is bigger. This doesn't means solid is weaker when size is the same. Already stated that with same cross sectional area, hollow would be stronger because it would have a bigger diameter.

[specialblend07]

How did I know Zilla gona copy n paste. Multiple dimensions ads a dimension and can increase strength in certain designs/applications. Real world experience talk

 

 

JT, c’mon this is BHQ we all know real world experience doesn’t matter. Google and some computer program even say so.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[trickedcarbine]

Zilla & Claude, why is JJ&A drilling vs using tube...? It's more work,why bother with it, if they are making a weaker product?

 

[locogato11283]

1 minute ago, trickedcarbine said:

Zilla & Claude, why is JJ&A drilling vs using tube...? It's more work,why bother with it, if they are making a weaker product?

 

Rotating weight.

[trickedcarbine]

4 minutes ago, specialblend07 said:

 

 

JT, c’mon this is BHQ we all know real world experience doesn’t matter. Google and some computer program even say so.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Correct me if I'm wrong, but JJ&A is gun drilling, correct?

 

[locogato11283]

Just now, trickedcarbine said:

Correct me if I'm wrong, but JJ&A is gun drilling, correct?

 

All but the play axles.

[JTmachining]

Zilla & Claude, why is JJ&A drilling vs using tube...? It's more work,why bother with it, if they are making a weaker product?
 

I’m def not either but in tube form the process to make the tube makes it not as good of a choice due to less strength etc compared to solid material