That's the simple fact. Whether Buyer/seller has 2 posts or 200, It's the Internet, you're taking a chance. Sad to say, but if I'm buying something from someone I don't know personally, I don't trust em! It's a role of the dice sometimes.
I'm an hour north of SD, I have some used Sand Stars on blue labels and some well used 9 paddle Haulers on brand new blue labels. Hit me up if you need em!